Skip to content

The Inner Conflict Between Lust, Caution

Sunday, December 2, 2007

色, 戒

Dir: Ang Lee

“But if you pay attention, nothing is trivial”

This is a messy, messy movie. Not in the way it was made — it’s Ang Lee Immaculate as always — but in the story that it tells, that of a situation where you just know nothing good will come out of it, there will be no real resolution, plans will fail and people will get hurt. The whole movie is basically a wait-and-wait-and-wait for the fall, and when it does come, it’s brutal.

The main focus is on the relationship between Mr. Yee (Tony Leung), a high-ranking official in the Wang Jing-wei collaborationist government centred in Shanghai in the late ’30s and early ’40s, and Wang Jia-zhi (Wei Tang), a young woman who is recruited by the Chinese resistance to infiltrate Mr. Yee’s circle and facilitate his assassination. I’m sure you can figure out just how she goes about her ‘infiltration’ simply by the name of the movie; but, of course, there is much more to it than that. While the film is getting a lot of attention because of the explicit sex scenes (it received an NC-17 rating in the U.S.), never before have I seen a movie where the sex is so intricately detailed and vital to character development, and where it is worked so expertly into the plot instead of just thrown in as either titillation or afterthought (although maybe I just haven’t seen enough European cinema).

Aside from this, there are actually quite a few common tropes throughout, such as an examination of role-reversals, and the main one which is the whole idea of ‘where is the line between facade and reality?’ But it’s done in such a crafty and detailed way that anticipation and curiosity overtake any feeling of ennui.

Wei Tang, without a doubt, deserves an Oscar nomination for her performance. She effortlessly moves between the various personae of her character (while portraying just enough of a show of effort to make her real); indeed, aside from one emotional outburst where she plainly speaks her heart, the majority of her story is told simply by the tone of her glances and varying set of her lips. Tony Leung tries to match Tang in subtlety, and in some places succeeds, but his performance feels somewhat clumsy next to her expert grace. If she doesn’t receive any recognition for this role it will be a definite shame, but I can see the film’s rating working against her here as it will severely limit its distribution (to wit, as of Nov 18/07, it’s only grossed $4 million).

The rating could also affect the film’s overall Oscar chances as well, given that there’s only been one ‘x-rated’ film in history to ever win anything, that of course being 1969’s Midnight Cowboy. Another couple of problems are the fact that the majority of the film is in Mandarin, and, most significantly, that it was disqualified as Taiwan’s entry into the Foreign Film category because not enough of the crew were actually Taiwanese (the Academy has quotas for these things). This means it will have to compete against all the English-language films, and while Lee did manage to pull that off before, with Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon being nominated for Best Picture, that film was also doubly nominated for Best Foreign Film, and everyone kind-of knew that he’d end up taking home that one as a sort of consolation prize. So this time around, unless the infamously elderly Academy members have their reading glasses primed and decide to risk over-excitement induced heart-attacks, this film could just fall into art-house obscurity.

Of Lee’s other films, this one reminds me most of the The Ice Storm, again in the way that its characters are trapped in an almost impossible situation from which no one can escape unharmed; but, while in that film the harm was in a societal-constructed tangle of emotional dishonesty into which you can see the characters marching full-force without a care, in Lust, Caution the reality of the day is war, betrayal, and carts which roam the streets to collect those who have starved to death in the night. The decisions that the characters make have actual life and death consequences, and as a result this film is grander in scope, I think, than anything that Lee has done before.

It will be very interesting to see what happens come award season. 03971semaj

7 Comments leave one →
  1. James17930 permalink
    Sunday, December 9, 2007 4:56 am

    Won 7 Golden Horse Awards yesterday, including Best Picture and Best Director. What a shock (click here for the story).

    An actual shocking thing was that Wei Tang didn’t win Best Actress — that went to her Lust, Caution co-star Joan Chen, for another film, The Home Song Stories.

  2. Monday, December 10, 2007 12:03 am

    You know, I don’t think this film is really that much in consideration for (Western) awards. It was one of the most eagerly anticipated at this year’s TIFF, but then when it showed most seemed to think it was a letdown. And its critical response was only moderately positive.

    That said, I think it was great, and my admiration for it grows the more I think about it. I doubt it’ll get any awards (and don’t really give a shit either way), though I’d say it’s best bet is for Wei Tang. Whether over- or underwhelmed by the movie, nobody’s denying how good she was. Her only real competition would be from Javier Bardem for No Country for Old Men, if only he wasn’t, you know, a dude.

    Also please note that I could’ve made upwards of eight lewd puns or asides in the above comment, and yet I chose not to. Though I know I’m gonna regret passing up that “my admiration grows” opportunity.

  3. James17930 permalink
    Monday, December 10, 2007 10:20 pm

    Duly noted.

  4. James17930 permalink
    Monday, March 10, 2008 2:07 am

    More retardedness from the Chinese government:;_ylt=AuFFSYnWKF4YNjiNdZuYG8_0kPUI

  5. James17930 permalink
    Tuesday, June 10, 2008 12:39 pm

    Graeme — you rented this yet?

  6. Tuesday, June 10, 2008 1:31 pm

    No, not yet. As it is, it’s pretty much a miracle that I’ve seen No Country For Old Men.

  7. James17930 permalink
    Tuesday, June 10, 2008 10:45 pm

    Well, you can rent movies through iTunes now, so that might be an easy way to go.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: